Sunday 12 August 2012

Arrogance or something else?

With the closing ceremony of the 2012 Olympics only hours away, I want to reflect on an aspect of the games that’s been getting a lot of airtime lately – the reactions of the medal winners, Usain Bolt in particular.

In the wake of the Jamaican 4x100m victory, I posted some remarkable statistics attesting to the strength and depth of the island’s pool of sprinters.  I was annoyed, (but not surprised) by the ensuing vitriol for the Jamaican team’s celebrations and those of Usain Bolt in particular.  “He’s an arrogant SOB,” quipped one person while someone else sided with Carl Lewis’ speculations that the Jamaicans had been doping all along.


In the wake of a Jamaican 1 2 3 in the 100m dash, Bolt was heavily criticized for taking a camera off a journalist and recording the moment for posterity.  
Picture courtesy of The Guardian

Why are we so quick to label confidence as arrogance?  Though there is a fine line between the two, I believe there’s a clear demarcation.  So let’s look at two Olympic happenings that, at least for me, helped chalk up the boundary.

The women’s 100m hurdles.  American and former world champion Lolo Jones places fourth behind compatriots Dawn Harper and Kelly Wells who manage a silver and a bronze.  Later in an NBC interview the two medal winners express their disgust at how Jones’s defeat is getting more airtime than their second and third place achievements.

US Athlete Lolo Jones.  
Picture courtesy of nationalconfidential.com

It turns out that Jones – a devout Christian and beautiful to boot – has been on the media “A” list for some time now.  Earlier this year, after tweeting that preparing for the Olympics was nowhere near as hard as preserving her virginity, the media spotlight turned on her with an intensity that few other members of Team USA experienced in the run up to the games.  

In the news industry, it’s the newsmen who decide what’s newsworthy, a fact that seems to have either eluded or been spitefully ignored by Jones’ fellow teammates.  Rivalry between sportsmen and women is to be expected – but jealousy over a fellow team member getting more media attention than you – especially when you won a medal – well that’s arrogance of the highest order.

Then of course there’s Usain Bolt and lesser-known Olympian Robert Harting.  Thanks to a few thoughtful journalists, we have an alternative explanation to the allegations of arrogance we’ve been hearing all along.  Of Bolt et al, Tim Adams of The Guardian says the following:

In among all the choreographed celebrations … there has always been just a trace of an emotion that it is hard to imagine the great sprinter owning up to: relief. Relief that his gift remains intact.  Relief that the gods continued to smile on him on this the biggest stage … Few athletes appear to show as much joy in victory as Bolt, but like all the greatest sportsmen you guess he is fuelled equally by a raging fear of defeat…

Though never televised, the reaction of German discus thrower could attract as much criticism as the Jamaican speedster.  Upon winning the Gold medal, Robert Harting ripped off his shirt, draped himself in his country’s flag and began bounding over hurdles which had been set up for the women’s 100m event.  Instead, Tony Manfred of Business Insider described Harting’s reaction as one of “adrenaline fueled passion and child-like joy”. 

Discus Gold Medal Winner, Germany's Robert Harting
Picture courtesy of Business Insider

So, perhaps what some have labeled “arrogance” is in fact a sublime form of relief alloyed with the unfettered and eruptive joy of vindication.  Which leaves one final question:  why does it make some people uncomfortable? 

Are we really that squeamish about success, particularly that of the inordinately gifted individual, the one with whom we could never hope to compete anyway?  Have we forgotten that the Olympics apart from being the rarefied litmus test of going faster, higher and further are a celebration of the human spirit too?

One Facebook friend wrote that the Brits actually loved the Jamaicans for their exaggerated celebrations and said, “their arrogance was not taken seriously”.  

Interestingly, she also said this:  “We Brits find it easier to fail than to show off”.

It was a courageous admission though probably not limited to the Brits.

No comments:

Post a Comment